Disclaimer: this is general information, not veterinary advice. We are pet parents and label-readers, not veterinarians or animal nutritionists. Talk to your vet before starting, stopping or changing any supplement.
Before you buy a pet supplement, ask the brand for its certificates of analysis. The direct answer: email the brand with the lot number from your package, ask for the certificate of analysis (COA) for that lot, ask who did the testing and what it covered, then put the report next to the label and write down anything that doesn’t line up. Bring the report and your notes to your vet.
We’re careful, budget-first shoppers and label-readers, not lab scientists. This page is the routine we use: what to ask for, how to compare a report with the label, what to write down, and which questions to hand to the brand or your vet so they can do the judging.
Asking for certificates of analysis: the basic routine
We keep it to five steps, every time:
- Photograph the panel. Take a clear photo of the full label, including the lot number and best-by date.
- Find the brand’s own contact. Look for a customer service email on the brand’s website rather than a retailer’s page.
- Send a short email. Use the template below, and include the lot number.
- Compare the reply with the label. Use the side-by-side worksheet further down.
- Take it to your vet. Bring the label photo, the report and your list of questions.
You don’t need to understand every line of a lab report. The routine is about collecting the right paperwork and asking clear questions.
Write down why you’re considering the product
Before you start chasing paperwork, spend five minutes on a short note. It keeps the vet conversation focused, and it helps you decide whether the product is worth the effort at all.
- What did you notice in your pet, and when did it start?
- Has anything else changed recently, such as food, treats, routine or household?
- Where did the idea for this product come from: your vet, a friend, an ad, a shop assistant?
- Has your vet already suggested a supplement, or would this be your own idea?
- Has your pet ever had a reaction to a food, treat or product before?
Write the answers in plain words. Your vet doesn’t need you to guess at a cause. They need to know what you saw.
Find the details on your package first
Before you email anyone, check the label for these and write them down. A brand will usually need them to find the right report.
- Product name, exactly as printed
- Size or count (for example, number of chews or grams)
- Lot or batch number
- Best-by or expiration date
- Where you bought it and roughly when
- Any quality seal or testing wording on the pack, copied word for word
If you can’t find a lot number anywhere on the package, write that down too. It becomes your first question for the brand.
A sample email you can copy
Keep it short and polite. You don’t need to explain why you’re asking.
“Hi, I’m considering [product name] for my dog. Could you share the certificate of analysis for lot [number on my package]? I’d also like to know who carried out the testing and what it covered. Thanks for your help.”
If you don’t hear back within a week or so, send one friendly follow-up. Note the dates you emailed and the date of any reply.
Questions to ask the brand
If the brand replies and you’d like more detail, these are the follow-up questions we send. Ask them in plain language, a few at a time.
- Ask the brand whether the report you received matches the lot number on your package.
- Ask the brand whether the testing was done by their own team, their manufacturer or an outside lab, and which lab.
- Ask the brand what the testing covered: the ingredients on the label, other screening, or both.
- Ask the brand whether every batch is tested, or only some.
- Ask the brand when the batch was tested, and how that date relates to the best-by date.
- Ask the brand whether they’re part of any quality program, and how you can check that.
- Ask the brand who makes the product and where.
- Ask the brand how to report a concern, and whether they keep records of reports.
For background reading, the National Animal Supplement Council publishes a page on its Quality Seal program, and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration publishes a page on how it regulates pet food.
When a report arrives: a first-read routine
Lab reports can look intimidating. We don’t try to interpret the numbers. We just run through the page in the same order every time:
- Find the product name at the top and check it against your label photo.
- Find the lot number and check it against your package, digit by digit.
- Find the date, and write it down.
- Find the name of whoever did the testing, and write it down.
- Count how many tests are listed, and note whether each one is marked pass or fail.
- Highlight any words or units you don’t recognise, so you can ask about them.
A side-by-side worksheet: report vs label
When a report arrives, put it next to your label photo and fill in this table. You’re not judging the results. You’re noting what matches, what’s missing and what you don’t understand.
| Check | On the label | On the report | Match? / Question |
|---|---|---|---|
| Product name | |||
| Lot or batch number | |||
| Each ingredient listed on the label | |||
| Amount stated for each ingredient | |||
| Other tests listed on the report | n/a | ||
| Pass or fail marked for each test | n/a | ||
| Test date | n/a | ||
| Best-by date | n/a | ||
| Name of the lab or tester | n/a | ||
| Who signed or approved the report | n/a |
Circle any line where the label lists something the report doesn’t mention, and add it to your question list for the brand.
Write down how the brand answered
How a brand responds is useful information in itself. We keep a short note for each brand we contact, without drawing conclusions. Note whether:
- They replied, and how long it took
- They sent a report, or only a general statement
- The report showed your lot number
- They named who did the testing
- The report had a date
- They answered your follow-up questions directly
- They offered health promises instead of answers
Bring these notes to your vet along with the report. Your vet can help you decide what, if anything, the gaps mean for your pet.
A budget check before you buy
Price and paperwork are separate questions, so we look at both. Here’s the routine:
- Check the label for the serving size and the number of servings in the container.
- Work out the price per serving: divide the price by the number of servings.
- Next to each price per serving, note whether the brand sent a report for your lot.
- Compare two or three options side by side, using the worksheet above for each.
- If your budget is tight, tell your vet, and ask whether there’s a lower-cost option they’d be comfortable with.
A higher price doesn’t tell you a product has been tested, and a lower price doesn’t tell you it hasn’t. The only way we know is to ask.
Your copyable one-page list
Copy this into a notes app or print it, one per product:
- Product name and size:
- Lot number and best-by date:
- Where and when I bought it:
- Price per serving:
- Date I emailed the brand:
- Date of reply, and who replied:
- Report received (yes/no), and does the lot number match:
- Who did the testing, according to the brand:
- Lines on the label that aren’t on the report:
- Questions for the brand:
- Questions for my vet:
After you buy
If your vet gives the go-ahead and you buy the product, close the loop at home:
- Save the report and the brand’s emails in one folder, labelled with the product name and lot number.
- Photograph the label of the tub you actually received, and check its lot number against the report.
- Write down what your vet suggested: product, serving and how long to try it.
- Note the start date, and keep a one-line daily log of appetite, energy, toilet habits and anything else you notice.
- When you buy a new tub, check the lot number again. If it’s changed, ask the brand for the report for the new lot.
Write what you see, not what you think it means. Your vet can do the interpreting.
When to call your vet
- You’re considering any new supplement for your pet.
- Your pet takes medication or has an ongoing health condition.
- A brand’s answers leave you unsure whether to start or continue a product.
- Your pet seems unwell after starting any new product.
- Your pet has swallowed a large amount of any product, or you think something may be poisoning. Contact your vet or an emergency clinic right away, or the ASPCA Animal Poison Control Center or Pet Poison Helpline, and keep the packaging and any report you received.
Questions to ask your vet
- Does my pet need this supplement at all on their current diet?
- Would you look over this certificate of analysis with me?
- Is there anything on this report, or missing from it, that you’d ask the brand about?
- Are there brands or quality programs you prefer, and why?
- Could this product affect any medication my pet takes?
- What should I write down while my pet is on it?
- Is there a budget-friendly option you’d be comfortable with?
Further reading
- National Animal Supplement Council: NASC Quality Seal
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration: FDA’s regulation of pet food
Ask for the report, match it to your lot number, write down what you find, and bring anything unclear to your vet.